A photograph posted by former Georgia Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene on X (formerly Twitter) has sparked speculation about the formation of a new political movement among former allies of former President Donald Trump, including conservative commentator Tucker Carlson and Rep. Thomas Massie (R-KY). The image, shared Saturday, shows Greene alongside her husband, Brian Glenn; Carlson; Massie; and Joe Kent, the former director of the National Counterterrorism Center, alongside their spouses. Greene’s accompanying post stated: ‘We said no more foreign wars, and we meant it and supported Donald Trump because he made that promise. But he’s betrayed us all. Our commitment is America First for all Americans, right, left, and center. The movement has begun.’
The gathering follows months of growing tensions between Trump and some of his most vocal supporters over foreign policy decisions, particularly the 2025 U.S. airstrikes on Iranian nuclear sites and the handling of the Jeffrey Epstein files. Greene had previously announced in June 2025 that she was ‘DONE’ with the Republican Party, writing: ‘There is A LOT of us that are absolutely fed up and will not support a party that betrays its voters and country.’ Carlson echoed similar sentiments in a June 2025 post, stating: ‘I’ve voted Republican my entire life… but there is no defending this… Because it’s immoral and it’s exactly the opposite of what a political party in a democracy is charged with doing.’
Massie, who lost his primary in Kentucky after Trump endorsed a rival candidate, had previously criticized Trump’s signature tax legislation and pushed for the release of the Jeffrey Epstein files. Kent, a former counterterrorism official, resigned in protest over U.S. involvement in the Iran conflict and what he described as undue Israeli influence in American politics.
The photograph, which has garnered over 9.5 million views on X, has fueled speculation about whether the group intends to launch a new political party or movement. Brian Glenn, Greene’s husband and a former White House correspondent, declined to discuss specifics of the meeting but acknowledged a ‘hunger for an alternative to Trump’s vision on the right.’ The gathering has been framed by some as a potential ‘America First’ splinter group, though its long-term viability remains unclear.
Policy Disputes Fueling the Split
The rift between Trump and his former allies centers on two key issues: foreign military intervention and government transparency. Greene, once one of Trump’s most vocal defenders in Congress, criticized his 2025 decision to authorize strikes on Iranian nuclear sites, calling it a ‘complete bait and switch’ on campaign promises. She stated: ‘We promised no more foreign wars, no more regime change.’ Kent, who resigned as director of the National Counterterrorism Center in protest, cited similar concerns about U.S. involvement in the Iran conflict and alleged Israeli influence in American foreign policy.
The Jeffrey Epstein files emerged as another point of contention. Greene met with Epstein survivors in September 2025 and publicly expressed belief in their accounts, a stance that contrasted with Trump’s administration, which had not prioritized the release of the files. Massie, who lost his primary after Trump backed an opponent, had been a vocal advocate for transparency regarding Epstein’s associates.
Reactions and Speculation
The photograph has drawn mixed reactions, with some supporters praising the group’s defiance of Trump’s leadership and others questioning the feasibility of a new movement. The Tucker Carlson Network reported 1.53 billion views across social media and podcast platforms in the eight-and-a-half weeks following the Iran conflict, suggesting a significant audience for alternative conservative voices. The post by Greene has accumulated 74,000 likes, 13,000 reposts, and 13,000 comments, indicating substantial engagement.
However, analysts note that converting online engagement into real-world political organization remains a challenge. The group’s ability to mobilize voters, secure funding, or challenge established party structures has yet to be demonstrated. Some observers describe the gathering as a symbolic show of dissent rather than the beginning of a formal political party.
What Comes Next?
The group has not publicly outlined a formal plan for next steps, though Greene’s post suggests an ‘America First’ movement is in its early stages. The term ‘America First’ has historical significance in U.S. politics, previously associated with isolationist and nationalist movements. The group’s stated commitment to representing ‘right, left, and center’ Americans could signal an attempt to broaden its appeal beyond traditional Republican voters.
Political analysts are divided on whether this alliance will gain traction or remain a niche faction. Some argue that the group’s shared criticism of Trump’s foreign policy could resonate with voters disillusioned by his administration’s actions. Others caution that lack of institutional support, funding, or clear policy proposals may limit its impact. The absence of high-profile endorsements or organizational structures further complicates predictions about the movement’s future.