Manchester United’s leadership is evaluating the future of manager Michael Carrick amid the club’s ongoing struggles in the Premier League. Chief executive Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox are meeting with Sir Jim Ratcliffe in Monaco today to discuss the club’s direction, with Mauricio Pochettino identified as a leading candidate to replace Carrick if a decision is made to part ways.
Carrick, 45, arrived at the club’s Carrington training ground at 7:45am on Wednesday in his Land Rover, where he was photographed giving a thumbs-up to the media. His future remains uncertain as the club’s hierarchy deliberates over his position. United sources state no final decision has been reached, and any announcement would require approval from co-chairmen Joel and Avram Glazer. A face-to-face meeting with Carrick is expected before any official confirmation, which may not come until Thursday.
Defensive struggles and leadership concerns
Manchester United currently sits in 18th place in the Premier League with just 8 points from 10 matches, the club’s worst start since 1986. Defensive issues have been particularly pronounced, with the team conceding 19 goals—a tally matched only by newly promoted Coventry City, whose squad costs roughly one-third of United’s. Injuries and lack of depth have forced frequent lineup changes, while team performance metrics, such as distance covered and average maximum speed, rank among the league’s lowest.
Criticism has not been limited to results. Midfielder Bruno Fernandes publicly called out his teammates following a 4-1 Champions League loss to Como last month, stating: “Not much pressure on the ball, not really many good movements without the ball.” Fernandes was subsequently benched for his comments. Despite the team’s struggles, some fans have continued to show support for Carrick, chanting his name after recent defeats.
Financial and contractual implications
If Carrick is dismissed, Manchester United would add to its recent compensation payouts, which have totaled nearly £30 million over the past three years under Ratcliffe and Ineos ownership. Additionally, hiring Pochettino would require buying him out of his contract with the US national team, an estimated cost of £7 million.
United’s leadership has emphasized that no final decision has been made, though the club’s recent form and internal discussions suggest a high-stakes review is underway. The outcome could reshape the club’s short-term trajectory and financial commitments.