The U.S. Department of the Interior is advancing a plan to allow offshore oil platforms off the coast of California to be toppled in place rather than fully removed when decommissioned. The proposal, outlined in a September executive order on recreational fishing, directs the newly formed Marine Minerals Administration to establish a federal "reef-in-place" program for decommissioned platforms.
The Interior Department has scheduled rulemaking for 2027 to make "toppling in place" the default decommissioning method if approved. This approach would involve knocking all or most of the platform over onto its side to rest on the sea bottom. While such methods have been used in the Gulf of Mexico, they have never been attempted in Pacific waters off California, where all previously decommissioned platforms have been fully removed.
There are 23 platforms in federal waters off California, eight of which are in various stages of decommissioning. An additional four platforms are located within state waters. Federal estimates suggest that full removal of some of the largest platforms could cost upward of $200 million per structure.
The proposed change has drawn criticism from environmental and conservation groups, who argue that the policy would primarily benefit fossil fuel companies by significantly reducing their decommissioning costs. Supporters of the plan, including some industry advocates, contend that the structures could serve as artificial reefs, potentially benefiting marine ecosystems.
The Interior Department has not yet released a detailed rationale for the policy shift, but the move aligns with broader federal efforts to streamline offshore energy infrastructure management. The department has indicated that the rulemaking process will include public comment periods before finalizing the new standards.
Offshore oil platforms in California have been decommissioned using full removal methods since the practice began in the state. The last platform removed in California waters was the Holly platform, decommissioned in 2016. Environmental assessments conducted during prior decommissionings have noted potential ecological impacts from both full removal and partial abandonment, though the long-term effects of leaving structures in place remain a subject of scientific debate.
The federal government holds jurisdiction over decommissioning standards for platforms in federal waters, while state agencies regulate those in state waters. California has historically opposed partial decommissioning methods, citing concerns about marine habitat disruption and long-term environmental risks. The state has not yet indicated whether it will challenge the federal proposal.