WASHINGTON — Senator Maria Cantwell, the top Democrat on the Senate Commerce Committee, has accused Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick of failing to enforce export controls on advanced AI chips bound for China, calling his inaction a threat to U.S. national security.
In a Nov. 15 letter to Lutnick, seen by multiple outlets, Cantwell stated that the Commerce Department’s refusal to act on repeated warnings from other agencies—including the Treasury, Pentagon, State Department, and U.S. Trade Representative—has "undermined America’s technological advantage in AI."
The letter follows new scrutiny of the Commerce Department’s enforcement record under Lutnick, with former officials alleging a yearlong halt in adding entities to the Entity List, which bans foreign firms from purchasing restricted U.S. technology. The last Entity List addition occurred on Oct. 9, 2025, marking the first such gap in 18 years, according to federal records.
Key Developments
- Cantwell’s Letter: The senator demanded Lutnick use his authority under the 2018 Export Control Reform Act to enforce restrictions on AI chip sales to China, citing what she described as the department’s "inexplicable refusal" to act on national security concerns.
- Bipartisan Criticism: Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has publicly blamed the Commerce Department for delaying the blacklisting of Singapore-based Megaspeed, a company linked to Nvidia’s former CEO Jensen Huang and an alleged Chinese spy, Alice Huang. Bessent stated that multiple agencies supported blacklisting Megaspeed for months but were overruled by Commerce.
- Former Officials’ Testimony: Four former Commerce Department employees told CBS News that the agency under Lutnick experienced "chaos," "micromanaging," and a complete stop in adding entities to the Entity List for a year. One former official called it an "inexplicable refusal to use the tools at their disposal for national security."
Policy and Political Responses
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has been vocal in his criticism of the Commerce Department’s inaction. In a CNBC interview, Bessent stated:
"I am frustrated when President Trump made it very clear that China should not receive any Nvidia chips above H100s. The Commerce Department has the pen, and you will have to ask them about their internal process."
Bessent’s remarks align with reports that Trump has privately supported blacklisting Megaspeed but has not taken direct action against Lutnick. President Donald Trump suggested Lutnick may have delayed enforcement to avoid straining U.S.-China relations, stating:
"He might have delayed it, but he was doing that because if you didn’t delay it, you could have a blow-up with China."
Trump, who is traveling to China for high-stakes meetings with Chinese President Xi Jinping, downplayed the dispute as a difference of opinion between cabinet officials.
Megaspeed and the Nvidia Connection
The controversy centers on Megaspeed, a Singapore-based data-center firm that has been investigated for allegedly facilitating the transfer of restricted Nvidia AI chips to Chinese entities. Nvidia’s H100 and H200 chips are subject to U.S. export controls, requiring government approval for shipment to China.
- Megaspeed’s Response: The company stated in a Nov. 17 statement that Alice Huang left the firm in August 2025 and that its operations are "legitimate and lawful." It denied any wrongdoing and noted that it has not been found to have violated export rules.
- Nvidia’s Role: Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia CEO in October 2025 amid reports of an affair with Alice Huang, whom U.S. intelligence agencies suspected of being a Chinese spy. China has dismissed the allegations as a smear campaign.
Commerce Department’s Stance
A spokesperson for Lutnick declined to comment on Cantwell’s letter. The Commerce Department has not publicly addressed the allegations of inaction, though it announced a new rule this week aimed at preventing Chinese entities from accessing restricted U.S. computing technology through data centers in third countries. The rule was developed at the direction of the Treasury Department and National Security Council.
Broader Implications
The dispute highlights growing tensions within the Trump administration over how to balance economic competition with China and national security concerns. While some officials, like Bessent, advocate for stricter enforcement of export controls, others, including Trump, appear to prioritize diplomatic stability.
Senator Cantwell’s letter signals that Congressional Democrats are intensifying pressure on the Commerce Department to take action before Trump’s meetings with Xi. The outcome of these deliberations could determine whether the U.S. tightens or loosens restrictions on AI chip exports to China in the coming months.