The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear an appeal from the Trump administration seeking to reinstate the cancellation of $324 million in federal research grants awarded to University of California researchers. The decision leaves intact a Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that found the terminations likely violated the First Amendment by suppressing viewpoints associated with diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives.
The grants, administered by the National Science Foundation (NSF) and the National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH), were abruptly terminated in April 2025 after President Donald Trump issued executive orders directing agencies to align funding with his administration’s priorities opposing DEI programs, climate change research, and gender ideology. Affected researchers received letters stating their projects no longer fit "agency priorities."
Key Developments:
- The Supreme Court’s order did not include a dissent or explanation, as is common when justices refuse to hear a case.
- The Ninth Circuit previously ruled that the terminations amounted to viewpoint suppression, violating constitutional free speech protections.
- Six UC researchers filed a class-action lawsuit seeking to reinstate their grants, with additional claims pending in the Court of Federal Claims for lost funding.
Background & Context
Federal Actions and Legal Challenges
The Trump administration’s January 2025 executive orders directed federal agencies to terminate grants tied to DEI-related keywords, including terms like "diversity," "equity," "environmental justice," and "climate change." Agencies complied by conducting keyword searches of grant applications and canceling awards that included these terms. The NSF and NEH suspended at least 18 grants to UC Berkeley alone, despite a prior court injunction restricting such suspensions.
Legal challenges followed, with researchers arguing the terminations discriminated based on viewpoint. Both a federal judge and the Ninth Circuit sided with the plaintiffs, finding the cuts violated the First Amendment. The appeals court, however, ruled that plaintiffs must file a separate lawsuit in the Court of Federal Claims to seek financial restitution for lost funding.
Scope of the Funding Dispute
The $324 million in terminated grants represents a portion of a broader effort by the Trump administration to redirect federal research dollars away from projects deemed inconsistent with its policy priorities. While some funding has since resumed, the legal battle over the terminated awards remains unresolved. The case highlights ongoing national debates over academic freedom, government funding priorities, and the role of DEI in federally supported research.
Reactions and Implications
Supporters of the terminated grants, including academic institutions and free speech advocates, hailed the Supreme Court’s decision as a vindication of constitutional protections. Critics of DEI initiatives, however, argue the ruling allows taxpayer dollars to fund programs they contend promote "ideological preferences" over merit-based research. The case underscores the politicization of federal research funding and the legal challenges that arise when executive orders clash with institutional autonomy.
What’s Next?
The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the appeal does not resolve the underlying dispute over whether the terminated grants should be reinstated or compensated. Researchers may pursue further legal action in the Court of Federal Claims, while the Trump administration retains the authority to revise its grant review processes. The decision also sets a precedent for future cases involving government attempts to terminate funding based on ideological grounds.
For now, the Ninth Circuit’s ruling stands, and the terminated grants remain canceled unless new legal developments intervene.