British Prime Minister Andy Burnham has announced three tests his government will apply to any new agreement with the European Union, framing the conditions as necessary to improve the existing Brexit deal. The announcement comes ahead of a UK-EU summit in Brussels on November 20, where Burnham seeks to secure agreements on food and farming, emissions trading, and youth mobility.
In a speech at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in London on November 16, Burnham stated that any deal must respect Labour’s 2024 manifesto red lines, improve the current Brexit arrangement, and pass the ‘Makerfield test’—a reference to his constituency, which voted to leave the EU in 2016. He described the approach as a shift toward constructive engagement rather than adversarial relations with Brussels.
Burnham has repeatedly criticized the 2020 Brexit deal negotiated by Boris Johnson, arguing it delivered a ‘harder Brexit’ than promised and has left the UK in a weaker position on immigration and economic stability. In prepared remarks, he is expected to say: ‘The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained.’
Part 1: Immediate Action & Core Facts
Prime Minister Burnham’s government has set three explicit conditions for any new EU agreement, which he will present as part of a broader ‘reset’ in UK-EU relations. These conditions are:
- Alignment with Labour’s manifesto red lines, including no return to the EU customs union, single market, or freedom of movement.
- Tangible improvements to the existing Brexit deal, particularly in trade, regulatory alignment, and cost-of-living pressures.
- The ‘Makerfield test’, requiring that any changes demonstrably improve ‘everyday lives’ for British citizens.
The summit in Brussels will focus on practical areas of cooperation, such as food and farming standards, emissions trading, and youth mobility programs. Burnham has framed these as short-term wins to ease friction caused by Brexit, while leaving open the possibility of longer-term discussions on the UK’s future relationship with the EU.
Part 2: Deeper Dive & Context
Government Rationale and Objectives
Burnham’s push for closer ties with the EU represents a departure from his predecessor, Keir Starmer, who ruled out rejoining the EU’s single market or customs union in Labour’s 2024 manifesto. Burnham has suggested that ‘any agreement must respect those red lines’ while still seeking to ‘improve the Brexit deal’ and address its perceived shortcomings.
In a speech excerpt released by his office, Burnham stated: ‘It’s like the emperor’s new clothes – where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth. Well, I say it as I see it. And to be frank, the emperor has nothing on. The Brexit we were given has not worked.’ He has also highlighted issues such as rising household bills, business costs, and the small boats immigration crisis as evidence of Brexit’s negative impact.
Political Reactions and Divisions
Burnham’s approach has sparked internal divisions within his government and among Labour’s allies. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood and Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy have expressed concerns about the direction of policy, while Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband described the upcoming summit as a ‘first step’ rather than a full reversal of Brexit.
Labour’s trade union allies have also pushed back. Gary Smith, general secretary of the GMB union, cautioned against ‘fully rejoining’ the EU, stating: ‘We can’t go back to where we were before.’ A source from Unite the Union echoed this sentiment, saying the union’s position is to ‘get as close as possible without rejoining.’
Public Opinion and Polling
Public sentiment toward Brexit has shifted since the 2016 referendum. Ipsos polling from June 2026 found that 52% of respondents favored rejoining the EU, with support rising to 58% among likely voters in a future referendum. A YouGov survey in the same month showed 57% believed leaving had been the wrong decision, while 55% supported rejoining—though support dropped to 35% if rejoining required surrendering opt-outs like the euro or Schengen free movement area.
Brexiteer Opposition
Supporters of Brexit have criticized Burnham’s plans. Former Prime Minister Boris Johnson has hinted at a political comeback if Labour pursues EU membership, while Brexiteers argue that Burnham’s approach ‘burns the bridges’ Johnson built. Critics contend that the current deal, while imperfect, provides the UK with greater sovereignty than full EU membership would allow.
Long-Term Implications
Burnham’s willingness to reopen the Brexit debate introduces uncertainty about the UK’s long-term relationship with the EU. While his immediate focus is on practical improvements, his rhetoric and the ‘Makerfield test’ leave open the possibility of future discussions on deeper integration. However, Labour’s manifesto red lines and union opposition suggest that full rejoining remains unlikely in the near term.
Background: The Brexit Legacy
The 2016 referendum resulted in a 52%-48% vote to leave the EU, with majorities in England and Wales supporting Brexit, while every Scottish council area voted to remain. The UK formally left the EU on January 31, 2020, under Johnson’s leadership, and the Trade and Cooperation Agreement took effect on January 1, 2021. Critics argue that the deal has led to increased bureaucracy, trade barriers, and economic strain, while supporters contend it has restored UK sovereignty.