In his first-ever television interview, Billy Evans, partner of disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes, confirmed that he voluntarily relinquished a tens of millions of dollars profit-sharing agreement from the A24 documentary You Can See Everything. The film, which grossed over $90 million worldwide on a $7 million budget, portrays Evans in a contentious light, including scenes that have drawn public criticism and threats against him.
Evans, speaking to CBS News’ Sunday Morning, stated that the profit share would have amounted to a "pretty silly" sum—estimated in the tens of millions—but he chose not to claim it. When pressed on where the money went, Evans replied, "I don’t know how much I can talk about, but what I can say is, knowing where the money’s going, I’m not unhappy about that decision." He declined to elaborate further, and representatives for A24, Nathan Fielder, and Lance Oppenheim did not respond to requests for comment.
Evans, who co-founded the blood-testing startup Haemanthus, said he earns little from his work and has spent significant sums on legal fees and childcare for his two young children. "The amount of money spent on lawyers would blow your mind," he noted, adding that seeking a share of profits was "reasonable" given his financial circumstances. He later clarified that his decision was not solely about money but also to demonstrate that the documentary was not about financial gain.
Evans Faces Backlash Over Documentary Depiction
The documentary, co-directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, has sparked intense debate over its portrayal of Evans. In the film, Evans is shown negotiating a profit-sharing agreement with the filmmakers, only to ultimately waive his rights to earnings. The documentary also includes scenes that some viewers interpret as depicting Evans as controlling or exploitative toward Holmes, who was convicted in 2022 of four counts of wire fraud for misleading investors about Theranos’ technology.
Evans pushed back against these interpretations, telling CBS News that the film’s portrayal of him was not reflective of reality. He acknowledged that the documentary had thrust him into an unwanted spotlight, describing the weeks since its release as "pretty crazy." Evans also disputed claims that Fielder may have been infatuated with Holmes, stating, "I think Nathan cares a lot about Elizabeth, and I didn’t get the impression for a minute that it was romantic."
Threats and Public Reaction
Evans revealed that he and his family have faced violent threats since the documentary’s release. He recounted an incident where a man screamed at him at a stoplight, threatening to harm his children and using "the most vile things you have ever heard." Evans described the experience as "terrifying", emphasizing that his primary concern was the safety of his family.
Criticism of Evans has also come from Amanda Seyfried, who portrayed Holmes in the 2022 Hulu series The Dropout. In a Rolling Stone interview, Seyfried called Evans "disrespectful" and "aggressive" during a tense dinner scene featured in the documentary. She stated, "I don’t like the way he’s using this human being, his wife—the person he says he’s ‘building monuments of love’ to—as a tool." Seyfried added that she had not developed the same rapport with Evans as the filmmakers had during production.
Evans did not directly address Seyfried’s remarks in his CBS interview but reiterated his commitment to his family. "It’s super painful, but me being angry about it doesn’t help change it," he said.
Documentary’s Impact and Future
You Can See Everything has become one of the most commercially successful documentaries of 2024, drawing widespread attention for its intimate portrayal of Holmes’ final months before reporting to federal prison. The film’s box office success has amplified public scrutiny of Evans, who has become an unwilling public figure in the ongoing discourse surrounding Theranos’ legacy.
Evans, who describes himself as a father first and a devoted partner, said he shared his side of the story to ensure his perspective was heard. "You can’t lose your voice," he told CBS News, reflecting on the years of public scrutiny Holmes has faced. His interview marks one of the few opportunities for Evans to address the film’s reception and the fallout from its release.