The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to review a legal challenge to California’s requirement that doctors complete implicit bias training as part of their medical license renewal process. The decision leaves in place a lower court ruling that upheld the mandate, while three justices dissented, arguing the case raised significant First Amendment concerns.
Supreme Court declines review of Khatibi v. Yip
The high court’s refusal to take up the case, Khatibi v. Yip, means California’s 2019 law requiring implicit bias training for licensed physicians remains in effect. The law mandates that doctors complete 50 hours of approved continuing medical education every two years, with a portion dedicated to instruction on implicit bias and its impact on patient care. The state does not preapprove all course content but sets standards and may audit compliance.
Three justices dissent, citing First Amendment concerns
Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Neil Gorsuch dissented from the court’s decision not to hear the case, arguing that the mandate may compel private speech in violation of the First Amendment. In a statement accompanying the denial, Thomas wrote that the court’s own test for determining when speech constitutes government speech rather than protected private expression may require reconsideration. He emphasized that First Amendment protections do not disappear simply because a state heavily regulates speech.
The dissenting justices contended that the training requirement forces instructors to adopt state-approved viewpoints to maintain their medical licenses, raising concerns about compelled speech. The case was brought by physicians Azadeh Khatibi and others who argued that the mandate unlawfully interferes with their professional expression.
How California’s implicit bias training works
California’s continuing medical education (CME) requirements include standards for courses addressing implicit bias, which proponents describe as education on unconscious stereotypes that may affect clinical decision-making. The state allows private entities to organize and teach these courses, provided they meet established criteria. The law was passed in 2019 following research suggesting disparities in healthcare outcomes linked to implicit bias.
Opponents of the mandate, including the plaintiffs in Khatibi v. Yip, argue that the training compels doctors to endorse specific viewpoints on race and gender, violating their constitutional rights. Supporters, including state officials and public health advocates, contend that the training is a necessary tool to reduce healthcare disparities and improve patient outcomes.
The Supreme Court’s decision not to hear the case does not address the merits of the challenge but leaves the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals’ prior ruling intact. The case had sought to clarify the boundaries between government-mandated speech and protected private expression under the First Amendment.