A coalition of California prosecutors, law enforcement groups, and relatives of murder victims filed a lawsuit Monday asking the state Supreme Court to block Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute all 548 death sentences in California.
The lawsuit, filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation (CJLF) on behalf of 28 district attorneys, 31 relatives of murder victims, and several law enforcement and victims’ rights organizations, argues that Newsom’s executive clemency action violates state procedures. Specifically, the plaintiffs claim the governor cannot categorically replace death sentences with life imprisonment without parole without following required individual commutation protocols.
The legal challenge centers on two key claims: that Newsom failed to provide proper notice to victims’ families and that he did not conduct individualized reviews of each case before announcing the mass commutations. The CJLF’s filing states that the governor’s action disregards the legal process followed by jurors and judges in each case.
Newsom, a Democrat, announced earlier this month that he intends to commute the sentences of 548 people—529 men and 19 women—currently on California’s death row. In an open letter to constituents, he described the move as “among the most difficult of my career” and argued that “state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with” the state’s values.
The lawsuit asserts that the governor’s authority does not extend to blanket commutations and that the California Constitution requires the state Supreme Court to approve gubernatorial clemency decisions. The plaintiffs include Anne Marie Schubert, the former Sacramento County district attorney and current CJLF president and CEO, who stated in the filing that Newsom’s action overrides the legal judgments of those who participated in the original trials.
A representative for Newsom did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The lawsuit follows the governor’s executive order directing the state corrections department to prepare for the commutations, which would convert all death sentences to life without parole. The legal dispute marks the latest chapter in California’s long-standing debate over capital punishment, which has been under a moratorium since 2019 when Newsom issued a reprieve for all executions.