Sen. Tammy Duckworth (D-IL) has demanded the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) reverse its 'shoes-on' policy at airports, citing a classified report that found security vulnerabilities. In a letter to TSA Deputy Administrator Ha Nguyen McNeill, Duckworth called the policy a 'reckless act' and warned it was implemented 'without meaningful consultation with TSA.'
The policy, introduced by former DHS Secretary Kristi Noem in July 2023, ended a two-decade rule requiring passengers to remove shoes for screening. The change followed the 2001 'shoe bomber' incident, where Richard Reid attempted to detonate explosives in his shoes on a flight from Paris to Miami.
Duckworth's letter references a Department of Homeland Security (DHS) inspector general report that found TSA scanners cannot effectively screen shoes, creating a new security risk. The report was flagged as urgent in a 'Seven-Day Letter' to Noem, but no corrective action was taken. Duckworth called this failure 'outrageous, unacceptable, and dangerous to the flying public.'
The TSA and DHS did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Noem had also considered relaxing liquid restrictions, allowing medically necessary items over 3.4 ounces if declared. Duckworth recently reintroduced a bill to ease airport travel for parents carrying breast milk and breastfeeding supplies.
Deeper Dive & Context
Policy Origins and Justification
The 'shoes-on' policy was introduced as part of broader efforts to streamline airport security. Proponents argue it reduces congestion and improves passenger experience without compromising safety. The TSA has not publicly addressed the inspector general's findings or Duckworth's demands.
Security Concerns and Counterarguments
Critics, including Duckworth, argue the policy creates a gap in security protocols. The classified report suggests that threat items could evade detection, raising concerns about passenger safety. However, supporters of the policy maintain that advanced screening technology and other security measures mitigate these risks.
Related Policy Changes
Noem's tenure saw additional proposed changes to airport security, including potential relaxations on liquid restrictions. While most liquid limits remain in place, medically necessary items over 3.4 ounces are now allowed if declared. Duckworth's recent bill aims to address challenges faced by parents traveling with breast milk and breastfeeding supplies.