Cincinnati City Manager Sheryl Long has fired Police Chief Teresa Theetge, concluding a five-month investigation that found her leadership ineffective. Theetge, who served as chief for three years, was placed on paid leave last October. Long cited Theetge's failure to implement the city's Summer Safety Plan, which included increased police presence in high-crime areas, as a key factor in her termination. Theetge's attorney, Steve Imm, is scheduled to address the media on Friday, though it is unclear if Theetge will attend.
Theetge, a 35-year veteran of the Cincinnati Police Department, faced criticism for her handling of rising crime rates, including a viral downtown brawl last August that left a woman with neurological damage. Long stated that the decision was necessary to ensure effective leadership moving forward. Mayor Aftab Pureval, a Democrat, supported the decision, noting that Theetge had initially indicated she would step down but later demanded $7.5 million in severance. Imm has suggested litigation may follow if the city takes further action against Theetge.
The termination letter highlighted Theetge's poor communication and disagreement with the city's anti-violence plan. Long emphasized the need for strong leadership to address public safety concerns amid rising crime. Theetge's departure marks a significant shift in Cincinnati's law enforcement leadership as the city grapples with ongoing safety challenges.