New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani released an audit on Friday accusing federal immigration authorities of using aggressive and deceptive tactics to target city agencies. The audit, part of Executive Order 13, reviewed six city agencies—including the NYPD, Department of Correction, and Department of Social Services—to ensure compliance with the city’s sanctuary laws. The 19-page executive summary details interactions between agencies and federal authorities, recommending changes to close loopholes in the city’s policies.
Key Findings and Recommendations
The audit found a significant increase in detainer requests from federal immigration authorities, with the NYPD receiving 3,672 requests in 2025, up from just 99 the previous year. Despite the requests, the NYPD did not transfer any individuals to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The report also highlighted intensified targeting of city shelters by federal agents. Mayor Mamdani’s office emphasized that the findings will strengthen protocols for city agencies when interacting with federal authorities, ensuring all New Yorkers, regardless of immigration status, can safely access city services.
Background and Context
Executive Order 13 was issued by Mayor Mamdani upon taking office to fulfill a campaign promise to protect immigrant communities. The order mandated a public safety audit for six agencies to assess compliance with sanctuary city policies. The audit’s recommendations aim to address blind spots and ensure consistent adherence to the city’s non-cooperation stance with federal immigration enforcement.
Opposing Perspectives
While the audit highlights concerns about federal tactics, some critics argue that the city’s sanctuary policies may hinder cooperation with federal authorities on public safety matters. Former NYPD Chief of Department John Chell has previously discussed the challenges of balancing local and federal enforcement priorities, particularly in the context of protests and arrests related to immigration enforcement.