Bill Maher criticized California Democrats on his show 'Real Time with Bill Maher,' arguing that Mississippi and Texas are outperforming the deep-blue state on education and green energy—issues Democrats often prioritize.
Core Facts & Developments
Maher highlighted that Black fourth-graders in Mississippi are 2.5 times more likely to be proficient in math and reading than their peers in California, citing 2024 National Assessment of Educational Programs data. In reading, 19% of Black fourth-graders in Mississippi were proficient compared to 7% in California. In math, 22% of Mississippi’s Black students were proficient versus 10% in California.
Maher also claimed Texas has surpassed California in solar energy production and leads in wind and energy storage, despite California’s climate policies. He questioned how Texas achieves better environmental results without pro-climate policies.
Deeper Dive & Context
Education Disparities
Maher referenced a February 2026 New York Times article noting the stark contrast in educational outcomes for Black students between Mississippi and California. The data shows Mississippi ranking 9th in fourth-grade reading proficiency while California sits at 37th.
Energy Policy Debate
Maher contrasted California’s aggressive climate policies with Texas’s energy sector success, questioning the effectiveness of California’s approach. He noted Texas’s leadership in solar and wind energy despite lacking state-level climate policies.
Political Reactions
Maher framed his critique as constructive, saying, 'I say this with love,' but his remarks sparked debate. Some supporters of California’s policies argue that systemic factors, such as funding disparities and urban-rural divides, complicate direct comparisons. Others defend Texas’s energy sector as a result of market-driven innovation rather than policy.
Long-Term Implications
The discussion raises questions about the effectiveness of state-level policies in education and energy. While Mississippi’s gains in education are notable, critics argue that California’s higher spending and progressive policies should yield better results. Similarly, Texas’s energy success challenges assumptions about the necessity of strict climate regulations.